Advocates for Youth
Our Sister Sites
Abortion Stories - The 1 in 3 Campaign
MySistahs
YouthResource
Ambiente Joven
Amplify - A Project of Advocates for Youth

login  |  create an account

  • Amplify Menu

  • You May Also Like:

    Share This Article

    As much as I understand that fandom is all about loving an artist’s sound no matter what kind of music he or she puts out, I tip my hat to Beyonce fans for insisting that her relatively-new single, ‘Run the World (Girls)’ is an awesome song. A friend of mine heard it first and text me to tell me how busy it was – “I heard like 30 different instruments in the first 30 seconds. I swear I even heard a light saber in there somewhere”. For someone who’s a fan of Major Lazer, hearing this ungodly mash-up of ‘Pon De Floor’, a drum line, and God knows what else, it just makes me chuckle to hear anyone talk about how awesome it is. Without further ado, here are 5 reasons why I do not like ‘Run the World (Girls)’.

    1. In my humble opinion, it’s just a shitty song disguised as an anthem for female empowerment. That’s the gist of it.

    2. For all the posturing about female empowerment, the video still pushes the whole in-order-to-be-sexy-and-badass-I-must-wear-lingerie-and-gyrate-like-a-stripper agenda. I didn’t see one regular-looking woman in that video. Everyone was toned and slim like Victoria’s Secret angels and wore at most a size 4.

    3. I’m sick and tired of all the sexual imagery. Can’t this woman do an entire video with all her clothes on? Again, the lingerie. What does that have to do with running the world? Can we have just one video where Beyonce isn’t writhing semi-naked in some kind of skintight, almost crotch less wonder that screams at every woman “You’re a fatty ‘cos you don’t look like this” If B oozed any more sex-appeal she’d be a puddle of pheromones and lube.
    Whatever happened to ‘Nasty Girl’? You know,

    “Nasty put some clothes on, I told ya/Don’t walk out your house without no clothes on, I told ya…/Nasty put some clothes on, you lookin’ stank/Nasty where’s your pride, you should be ashamed…/Hard…for women like me who try to have some integrity/You make it hard…for girls like myself who respect themselves/And have dignity" 

    But I guess that doesn’t matter when you’re a diva and all. Those lyrics apply only to us common folk.

    4. I don’t know about you, but in order to run the world I don’t need to be “so hood like this” or “run this mutha”. Frankly speaking, I don’t need to RUN anything. Sneaking in a line about college grads and a 9 to 5 job doesn’t make it any better.
    Felonious Munk has something to say to all the ‘bad bitches’ out there who think they’re special because they have a degree and a job like everyone else.

    "This goes out to all my girls that’s in the club rocking the latest/Who will buy it for themselves and get more money later" 

    Yeah that’s smart. I forgot that it’s always better to be fashionable even if it means maxing out credit cards and living paycheck to paycheck. Silly me.

    5. Even while she’s hollering about how girls run the world because they’re so awesome, she’s still doing the whole ‘come hither’ thing, slinking around the boys like Ursula from ‘The Little Mermaid’ (although much better looking).

    "Boy I’m just playing, come here baby/Hope you still like me, If you hate me/My persuasion can build a nation/Endless power, with our love we can devour/You’ll do anything for me"

    *This is me confused* Why is your army doing the sexy version of the ‘Stanky Legg’ during a standoff with the SWAT team dudes?

    These are just a few things that stood out to me when I watched the video. I already watched it twice and refuse to do so ever again so feel free to check it out and contribute your own opinion.

    Categories: Uncategorized
    • Mary

      Thank you for this. I agree with you completely. It’s not that I think Beyonce is particularly bad for what she is (a mainstream pop artist that produces superficial music and uses sex appeal to sell it, just like any other). It’s just that all the praise she gets is sickening and unwarranted. The image of “integrity” she tries to sell, which for some reason most people buy into, seems so forced to me. I’m not making a character judgment here, as I don’t know who she is as a person. But that’s the point: as a public figure, her actions don’t show her to be this paragon of class and dignity everyone claims she is.

      Personally, I find her constant “girl power” anthems patronizing. I can’t stand the smothering, empty messages of “empowerment.” Especially all the Destiny’s Child songs where they take a holier-than-thou attitude for being financially independent, or give “independent women” inordinate praise merely for making their own living. That’s simply expected of men, but I guess we women are like babies and need to be pat on the back and praised for doing the bare minimum we need to survive. Thanks for the empowerment!

      Watching the Rule the World video, I couldn’t help but think it was the opposite of empowering to watch her use her sexuality–surely the only weapon in a female’s arsenal!–to combat men. I also couldn’t help but think it was extremely immature to take a “boys vs. girls” stance; in fact, the whole song is just reverse sexism. She’s popularizing the idea that feminism=feminazi, which is detrimental to women’s progress.

      I laugh whenever people say “I don’t just like her because she’s beautiful and talented. She’s down to earth and respects people.” Do people actually listen to lyrics? What’s down to earth and respectful about flaunting your sex appeal constantly, bragging about the fact that you’re financially independent, degrading the opposite sex? She gets rough with some of the guys in the video. Imagine the backlash if a male did the same to a female in a music video.

      Sorry for the rant; just had to share my thoughts because everyone I know who knows who Beyonce is looooooves her. I never get to talk to anyone who agrees she’s overrated, if not problematic. But my frustration isn’t with her, so much as the undiscerning mainstream audience. It’s possible to enjoy pop culture on a visceral level, while having a critical eye for it. But what I see people doing with celebrities like Beyonce is fall for all the marketing ploys and superficial messages. And try to attribute additional positive qualities to anyone who is beautiful and talented, to the point of ignoring the celebrity’s actions. Our culture’s worship of celebrities is ridiculous.